administration that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction, a pattern and a philosophy begins to emerge on both sides of the Atlantic that should alarm all Americans and Britons who are interested in freedom, peace or justice. The Irish, sitting between the jaws of this nut cracker, have little reason for equanimity either. It is clear that both governments give a much higher priority to their own power than they do to the liberty of their citizens, much less of their neighbors’.
Espionage, the accumulation of intelligence about the
potential and intentions of a nation’s enemies or
potential enemies, or the destruction of enemy targets
by deceit, is an accepted weapon of war. But this
activity, when practiced by any government against its
own citizens in violation of its own laws, is criminal,
even treasonous. Even potential cases against terrorists
have been compromised because of illegal wiretaps. In
The United States, the people’s remedy is to deny
re-election or to impeach. Since Bush can’t run for
president again anyway, and since, with a Republican
Supreme Court and Congress, he need not fear
impeachment, the only limitation on his conduct would be
his own character and patriotism, the lack of which
accounts for his arrogance in this situation.
In Ulster, the British have refused
to explain why they had charged a British agent with
spying for the IRA and had then dropped the charges.
Prime Minister Tony Blair has already admitted that the
government could “get in trouble” for what has
been done. In fact, exposure of the scandal further
endangers the fragile peace process, bringing into
question the good faith of all the parties, as each side
accuses the others of being the instigator. There is not
even agreement on whose cause Donaldson was actually
promoting. Was Donaldson a Sinn F’ein double agent? Is
Britain trying to destroy the peace initiative so that
the Crown, rather than the people of Ulster, will remain
in control? Are both Sinn F’ein and the British
conducting cover ups, as alleged by The SDLP, who
characterize the incident as replacing a dirty war with
a dirty peace? Was it The UUP who “outed”
Donaldson so as to re-energize the conflict?
The Gael are a unique people in many
ways, passionate, contentious, assertive; compulsively
generous and loving with a deep sense of family and clan
while, at the same time, they, like Clancy, love to
“lower the boom,” single mindedly holding grudges
and maintaining feuds for hundreds of years. I know this
because I too, am Gaelic. Although my family left the
old sod some 315 years ago, and left Islay 304 years
before that, none of us have lost the propensity to
“get our Irish up.” In addition to their innate
character, the people of Ulster, more even than the
other Gael of Ireland and Scotland, have ample reason
for anger and resentment, having been occupied,
persecuted and subjected to genocide by the English, and
by each other, for more than 900 years, and to this very
day.
But enough already! Let him who is without sin cast
the first stone! Has not enough blood been shed?
Isn’t a four hundred year war enough? No one but the
politicians, soldiers and war lovers really benefit
from the current argument, or from the troubles. Why
don’t you all just shut up, and give peace a chance.
(Didn’t your mother teach you that if you can’t say
something nice about somebody, you shouldn’t say
anything at all?) You might actually enjoy peace for
a change. But if democracy is to replace conflict in
Ulster, each side is going to have to actually
guarantee the rights of their opponents. Otherwise,
no one will have any rights.
And as to Bush and his high-handed
tactics, the American electorate will deal with him.
It may be another forty years before there is
another Republican majority in Congress. Enjoy it
while you can Georgie!
Monument to The Troubles
- Struell Wells, Co. Down
Site of one of the Sacred healing wells of Ireland

The coincidence of two spy scandals taking place at the same time, one involving George Bush ignoring the law and ordering the NSA to spy on thousands of American citizens without warrants, much as Nixon did in a prior Republican administration; and the other involving Sinn F’ein official Denis Donaldson being paid by the British to spy on his own organization, and then being exposed by someone within the government after Sinn F’ein renounced their armed campaign and his usefulness was exhausted, paints a sinister picture of both the British and U.S. governments under their current administrations. When we mix in the recent “outing” of CIA agent Valorie Plame Wilson as vengeance for her husband’s exposure of false claims by the


December, 2005 Comment